I’ve been in church nearly every Sunday of my life. I was taken there as a baby and I attended the morning my baby was born, squirming during every contraction. Church attendance is just part of who I am.
Six months ago I left the local church which I’d faithfully attended for several years. Why I left is not the topic of this post. What I want to talk about is the thinking I went through to find a new church. I’ve now found a new church and have decided that, at least for now, that church is going to be my local church which I will support and become involved in.
First, a little b***ground. I live in the southern half of the United States, in the Bible belt. In fact, I live in the Buckle of the Bible belt—there is a huge number of churches nearby in a variety of denominations, sizes, styles, color. Therefore, I had a lot of choices. The other thing I want to mention about my search for a church is that I wasn’t doing this alone. Quite probably the place I ended up would have been different if I had been church shopping only for my own needs and desires.
For me, there were Big Things, Medium-sized Things, and Little things that I considered while looking for a new local church. My list likely wouldn’t be the same as your list. Some things on my list aren’t very “spiritual,” I admit that. I’m just honestly telling what was important to me.
The Big Things
- Are they actually Christians? And is the church not so liberal as to deny the veracity of the Bible and the basic core Christian beliefs? I can tolerate a variety of doctrines. I feel quite free to worship and fellowship with believers with whom I don’t actually agree on all doctrinal points. I allow a generous amount of latitude in both Christian belief and practice. On the other hand, I really do believe the playing field does have real boundaries, and I won’t attend a church outside of the line.
- The place of scripture. I know that not all Christians interpret all scripture passages the same, but if a church uses anything but the message of scripture as its starting point, then what is the point?
- Location. This was a big one for me for some very specific personal reasons. For me, the church needed to be less than 10 miles away, and preferably less than 5 miles away. Due to my location, there were many choices within 5 miles.
- Does it work for my family? Because I’m not in this alone, I had to take the considerations of others into account. If I had an infant, I’d be very sure that my church had a decent and safe nursery. If I had school aged children, I’d be sure that my church had decent Sunday School and children’s education. If my husband were deaf, I’d be sure the church offered hearing aids. Etc. In other words, it isn’t just about me. I needed to take careful consideration of those I’m connected to.
The Middle-Sized Things
- Style of music. Churches have fits over music styles. Churches have two services to accommodate contemporary vs. traditional church music. Or they split over the issue. In my case, music style was a factor, but not a huge factor. It turns out that the church we’ve settled on uses a mix of contemporary and traditional music, but done only with piano, no guitars or drums (both of which are fine with me).
- Quality of music. I have to confess that this became more important to me as we visited different places. I found myself distracted and annoyed with mediocre musicians leading the corporate singing. I know not every church has the native talent to be of top quality. Even so, I personally found less than excellent musical quality to be a big downer.
- Programs that I want/need/am interested in. Not every church can be everything to every person. Churches do tend to specialize in the programs they choose to offer, and for good reason. For instance, one church may have lots of young families and they specialize in Christian education. Another church may be located in an economically depressed area and they may specialize in a soup kitchen and after-school programs. At the risk of sounding too much like a consumer, I personally see no problem with shopping for a church that has programs that fit the needs of me and my family as long as the Big Things come first.
- Quality of the preaching. I’m of the opinion that if a preacher is well-prepared, his or her preaching will not put me to sleep. I may or may not agree entirely with what is being said, but I can tell if a preacher has done their homework. (Preaching from the seat of one’s pants is not the same thing as spirit-filled preaching.) Also, a preacher’s education is important to me. I can hear the word of the Lord from a child or an uneducated bum, no doubt—but I want to be in a church where the pastor’s level of education is at least the same as mine, preferably higher.
The Little Things
- The building. For many, this would be entirely a non-issue. For me, I wanted a church with windows and a ceiling that didn’t give me claustrophobia. I appreciate religious art and religious symbols, too.
- Size. Does size matter? Size certainly makes a difference as far as what programs are offered, and it might make a difference as to the quality of the music. But mainly, size has to do with how much one wants to be visible—it is hard to hide in a small church, but quite easy to hide in a big one. I think size is pretty much a personal preference, but choosing a small church might combat a natural tendency to hang on the fringes.
- Racial mix. I admire churches that can pull off a mix of ethnic groups. The church I attended before did fairly well with this, but the church I’ve recently chosen doesn’t do so well. I hope they improve.
- Age mix. Some churches can pull off being multigenerational and actually offer meaningful programs for all ages. I don’t think most small churches can do this. And any church which keeps the age 18-34 (esp. unmarried or childless) demographic strong, must have something going for it.
- Denomination. For many people, this item would be a Big Thing. For me, it isn’t. I truly wish the Body of Christ were not splintered into denominations, but it certainly is. I’ve happily worshiped (and worked) with believers of many denominational stripes. I feel little need to declare myself a member of any denomination. In fact, I haven’t been a full church member of any denomination ever, in spite of faithfully attending and being involved with many. My reasoning is that I would find becoming a full member to be intellectually dishonest. To me, church membership means I agreed wholeheartedly with everything the denomination stands for; so far, I’ve not found a denomination in that category. Because of that, I’ve opted for associate membership or just no membership, in spite of being fully involved.
Some of you might say, “Well, what about the people and the fellowship?” My reply: that takes a little time. I wouldn’t be able to choose a church based on people and fellowship because those things aren’t evident until I’ve been there a while and some time has passed.

Chapter 5 starts out autobiographical again as Collins tells about the early days of DNA sequencing and how thrilling it was for him to discover the faulty DNA sequence that causes cystic fibrosis. He then tells about scientists arguing whether trying to map the entire human genome was a good idea or not, and spending an afternoon in prayer asking God’s guidance as to whether he should accept the directorate of the entire Human Genome Project. As a side story he tells about the heated debates about whether the information about the human genome should be kept as open source or whether it should be patentable. The chapter ends with a detailed study about the interrelatedness of all living things, pointing out that the DNA between a human and a chimpanzee is 96% identical.

It is that time of year again. When we were kids—admit it—we really hoped for a good haul on 

Recent Comments
Tom Degan
Darius, Jasen, Christopher Roussel
Colin, Jubal Biggs, Colin, Jubal Biggs, Jubal Biggs, Christopher Roussel [...]
Bryan Jenkins, Colin, Christopher Roussel, Colin, Christopher Roussel, Darius [...]
Bryan, B, Colin, Bryan, Christopher Roussel, Jew [...]